I must say I've been completely impressed with Hot, Flat, and Crowded. At first glance, I was afraid it was going to be a recycled Al Gore tirade on global warming, however it has turned out to be much more. Friedman brings a new perspective to the "Energy Climate Era", one that is inspiring and more than gloom and doom. Many of the ideas are not foreign to me, but the way he writes, adding in personal anecdotes and sections of articles from other publications is quite unparalleled.
There have, however, been some completely new ideas this book has brought about for me. Take for instance the entire chapter of "Fill 'er Up With Dictators: Petropolitics". I suppose, had I stopped and thought about it, and become more well read on foreign policy and how it relates to the demand for oil, I could have possibly come to some of the more elementary conclusions Friedman mentions. For instance, the idea that our demand for oil is "fueling an ugly energy scramble that brings out the worst in nations." However, I would have never begun to guess at some of the correlations he makes between our oil addiction and "funding both sides of the war on terror", or "helping finance a reversal of democratic trends", or certainly not the treatment of women abroad. On that note, one of my favorite quotes thus far has been, "Our own oil dependence is behind more bad trends domestically and around the world than any other single factor I can think of. Our addiction to oil makes global warming warmer, petrodictators stronger, clean air dirtier, poor people poorer, democratic countries weaker, and radical terrorists richer." (81) This is truly a wake up call that though we are separated by miles, we are one world, and whether we like it or not, in many ways we are interconnected. My other favorite quote was in regards to America leading the way in this energy crisis, Friedman wrote, "...it is essential going forward that a Code Green strategy...be included in America's gift bag to the world today, right along with the Bill of Rights, the Declaration of Independence, and the Constitution. Because without it, we are not going to be free much longer." (76)
I think I can use quite a few things from this book as I prepare for my presentation on the paradox of affluence as it relates to geography. Friedman is constantly talking about how the world is impacted (both the affluent and non-affluent) by the Energy Climate Era, which is exactly what I'm going to be talking about.
I'm excited about reading the rest of this book, and more good class discussions. I felt when we read Covey, we were all a bit bored, and didn't feel challenged by the material. Hopefully Friedman will continue to be both inspiring and thought provoking for us all.
Friday, March 13, 2009
Thursday, March 12, 2009
Friedman
Wow. There are so many things I like about this book already. I like the fact that Friedman says that America has a problem AND the world has a problem. In society today we kind of just look for help in other places and we don't really try to help ourselves...generally speaking. In times of crisis we start to look back through history in order to make the best possible decisions for the future. However, this doesn't really solve any of the problems because it leads us to where we are now. In the same situation...because we didn't reinvent it in any way. When I was reading this book I suddenly felt motivated to go green and to actually think about the world's problems in a different perspective.
I think that this book will definitely help me in writing about my Geography topic. I could probably throw in a few ideas concerning affluence in different countries based on natural resources. Just an idea...?
I also found several other ideas of Friedman's to be amazing as well. I love how he said that the world shouldn't be "post" anything. That we need to kind of pave the way of the future and just let go of these thoughts because they do not define who we are now. They are not where we are now. Also, the whole concept of "Energy-Climate Era" is genius. "I think we are at one of those bright-line moments in history when things could change in ways that we can hardly imagine and across a very broad number of areas simultaneously (27)." It goes on to say, "We have seen such moments before- the democratic revolutions of the Enlightenment or the Industrial Revolution, and in our own time, the information technology revolution. One thing they all had in common is that when things started changing, people could not initially grasp their full significance. Another thing they had in common was that with all these great changes came great challenges. And it was rising to those challenges that defined the new eras, drove progress, gave birth to new institutions, and separated the winners from the losers." AMAZING.
This book makes me want to become more aware of the world. I don't really watch the news or read newspapers because I used to find it all depressing. Like they have nothing good to say and only seem to point out the bad things. The media does in a sense persuade you and tell you what they want you to hear but I admire how Friedman still sees a way out. Although society is at its worst...there is still a chance of renewal. I am excited to continue reading this book, there's a lot of information to ingest but it's good so far. :)
I think that this book will definitely help me in writing about my Geography topic. I could probably throw in a few ideas concerning affluence in different countries based on natural resources. Just an idea...?
I also found several other ideas of Friedman's to be amazing as well. I love how he said that the world shouldn't be "post" anything. That we need to kind of pave the way of the future and just let go of these thoughts because they do not define who we are now. They are not where we are now. Also, the whole concept of "Energy-Climate Era" is genius. "I think we are at one of those bright-line moments in history when things could change in ways that we can hardly imagine and across a very broad number of areas simultaneously (27)." It goes on to say, "We have seen such moments before- the democratic revolutions of the Enlightenment or the Industrial Revolution, and in our own time, the information technology revolution. One thing they all had in common is that when things started changing, people could not initially grasp their full significance. Another thing they had in common was that with all these great changes came great challenges. And it was rising to those challenges that defined the new eras, drove progress, gave birth to new institutions, and separated the winners from the losers." AMAZING.
This book makes me want to become more aware of the world. I don't really watch the news or read newspapers because I used to find it all depressing. Like they have nothing good to say and only seem to point out the bad things. The media does in a sense persuade you and tell you what they want you to hear but I admire how Friedman still sees a way out. Although society is at its worst...there is still a chance of renewal. I am excited to continue reading this book, there's a lot of information to ingest but it's good so far. :)
Thomas Friedman: The man, the writer, the cross dresser?
Caron mentioned in her introduction to the theme of blog posting for the week that we might want to investigate a little further and dig up some dirt on Thomas Friedman and his credentials. Well, looking at his website, he seems fairly legit. But then upon investigating a little more, I found this interesting piece of literature on our buddy Friedman:
"She's devestated," explained someone close to Thomas Friedman's wife. "How would you feel if you married a man and discovered he was more interested in what was in your closet than what was in your heart? It's also true that, as a cross dresser, Thomas Friedman is more than a tad trashy. If you're husband is going to dress in women's clothing, you like to think that at least you can point to his sense of style. Instead, Thomas Friedman in drag looks like he's heading down the courtyard to pay the lease on the spot for his double-wide. He has gone from being her personal embarrassment to the embarassment of the 'New York Times.' There's even been loud whispers of drug use; however, he was wearing his red wig then and may have just gotten into that car crash because he was pretending he was Lindsay Lohan."
So even though our new friend is a cross dresser, I still like his book. I have found it to be really eye opening. I know we discussed it in class, but I love how he puts things into terms that we can truly understand, such as the cow story. I think as time progresses we will see works such as Hot, Flat, and Crowded become even more popular. While this can be a great thing, because it will make the population as a whole more informed on the issue how we are basically committing suicide as a planet, I think that until something drastic, like another ice age occurs, we will still as a nation continue to deny that anything is wrong. We will not act unless we are forced to act. This kind of response will lead to our demise as a planet.
Take for example a group project in school. The members of the group are are joking around and not doing their work. They know they need to do it, but it is just too much effort. They are happy with the way things are at the moment, and they do not want to think of the consequences down the road if they do not do their homework. But then, one student decides that they really must get to work if they are going to get the assignment done on time. The rest of the group laughs off this suggestion and refuses to work. The one student that wanted to work starts to take on the whole project themself, but eventually it is too much and they give up. The whole group suffers the failing grade, even though one student sincerely made an effort. Take this whole senario again, except this time the teacher is in the room making them do the work. They are not allowed to joke around or goof off, and therefore they get the work done and succeed.
I think the same concept applies to the hot, flat, and crowded situation we are seeing in the United States. To me the key is to act as a nation. I know some people may say it starts with the individual deciding to make a positive change, but in all honesty, even though this is a great concept, in the end their efforts will have little impact. Their effort will be squelched by the vast majority of people who are not willing too make a positive change on their own. I think it will take the government highly taxing gas or putting restrictions on fuel consumption that will truly lead to change. We may not like it at first, but we will get used to it. In the end it will save us from committing suicide as a planet. The United States needs to step it up as a nation and be the model for the rest of the world.
"She's devestated," explained someone close to Thomas Friedman's wife. "How would you feel if you married a man and discovered he was more interested in what was in your closet than what was in your heart? It's also true that, as a cross dresser, Thomas Friedman is more than a tad trashy. If you're husband is going to dress in women's clothing, you like to think that at least you can point to his sense of style. Instead, Thomas Friedman in drag looks like he's heading down the courtyard to pay the lease on the spot for his double-wide. He has gone from being her personal embarrassment to the embarassment of the 'New York Times.' There's even been loud whispers of drug use; however, he was wearing his red wig then and may have just gotten into that car crash because he was pretending he was Lindsay Lohan."
So even though our new friend is a cross dresser, I still like his book. I have found it to be really eye opening. I know we discussed it in class, but I love how he puts things into terms that we can truly understand, such as the cow story. I think as time progresses we will see works such as Hot, Flat, and Crowded become even more popular. While this can be a great thing, because it will make the population as a whole more informed on the issue how we are basically committing suicide as a planet, I think that until something drastic, like another ice age occurs, we will still as a nation continue to deny that anything is wrong. We will not act unless we are forced to act. This kind of response will lead to our demise as a planet.
Take for example a group project in school. The members of the group are are joking around and not doing their work. They know they need to do it, but it is just too much effort. They are happy with the way things are at the moment, and they do not want to think of the consequences down the road if they do not do their homework. But then, one student decides that they really must get to work if they are going to get the assignment done on time. The rest of the group laughs off this suggestion and refuses to work. The one student that wanted to work starts to take on the whole project themself, but eventually it is too much and they give up. The whole group suffers the failing grade, even though one student sincerely made an effort. Take this whole senario again, except this time the teacher is in the room making them do the work. They are not allowed to joke around or goof off, and therefore they get the work done and succeed.
I think the same concept applies to the hot, flat, and crowded situation we are seeing in the United States. To me the key is to act as a nation. I know some people may say it starts with the individual deciding to make a positive change, but in all honesty, even though this is a great concept, in the end their efforts will have little impact. Their effort will be squelched by the vast majority of people who are not willing too make a positive change on their own. I think it will take the government highly taxing gas or putting restrictions on fuel consumption that will truly lead to change. We may not like it at first, but we will get used to it. In the end it will save us from committing suicide as a planet. The United States needs to step it up as a nation and be the model for the rest of the world.
Monday, March 9, 2009
Hot, Flat, and Crowded -- linked here
So we transition to this text, and I hope you are reading this one, as it's a bit more engaging than our good friend Covey. A bit. I have attached Friedman's site, and using the text as well as the site, offer your own suggestions. As you see from the site, he is collecting recommendations from readers for his next volume -- perhaps your suggestion could be published?
As you read Hot, Flat, and Crowded, however, identify passages that open your eyes to new possibilities ... or open your mind to what has been happening. Perhaps even do a little more digging about Friedman -- is he legitimate? What are his credentials?
Finally, as you read the text, identify passages that are relevant to your topic. How will you use this text in your paper? This will take us up to Spring Break, so brainstorm, vent, rant, praise... whatever the reading incites in you, share some of that here.
As you read Hot, Flat, and Crowded, however, identify passages that open your eyes to new possibilities ... or open your mind to what has been happening. Perhaps even do a little more digging about Friedman -- is he legitimate? What are his credentials?
Finally, as you read the text, identify passages that are relevant to your topic. How will you use this text in your paper? This will take us up to Spring Break, so brainstorm, vent, rant, praise... whatever the reading incites in you, share some of that here.
Sunday, March 8, 2009
"Your not even a Nigger, your an African." ( Hotel Rwanda)
Hotel Rwanda
I hate this movie. Not because its a bad movie, but because I can no longer watch it without getting sick to my stomach. For those of you who don't know, Hotel Rwanda is a chronicling of the Rwandan Genocide.Specifically, the heroism of a man named Paul Rusesabagina. I believe that we've talked a little about this particular event in class, but, in order for you to understand why i can no longer watch this movie, i believe a little elaboration is in order. During the age of imperialism Rwanda was controlled by the Germans. Then, after WWI, the Rwandan territory was taken from the Germans and in trusted to the Belgians. While the Belgians where in control of Rwanda they decided that they needed a way to separate the ruling class from the working/lower class. The Belgians based this separation on a myriad of ridiculous and morally offenses grounds including, among other things, nose width and skin pigment.Belgians picked those with lightest skin pigment and thinnest noses to rule, essentially picking those Rwandans who resembled them most closely to rule. These two classes of people were known as Hutu and Tutsi. Hutu being the lower class with the vast majority of the population (as per the usual in human societies), Tutsi being the ruling class with a vast minority of the total population. Isn't it funny how those who are already affluent get to chose what affluent people look like?! Hilarious right?
Now that you know how and why these people were separated/ segregated, it wont be hard for you to understand why these two sides feuded when the Belgians left Rwanda to its own devises. I mean seriously imagine it, you live in Rwanda, your trying to simple survive, then some super power walks in and says " Hey how ya doin? We're Belgium and we are going to be ruling you now. The way we're are gonna do this is by separating you into two groups:the rich and the poor. So all of those with thin noses and light skin please step forward, and everybody else....you've go a lot of work to do." So obviously when the Belgians leave the lower class is going to be out for blood, and guess what that's exactly what happens! Who would have guessed that the majority of people who had been stripped of their rights, their land, their dignity, and pretty much everything else, would be pissed?
It is this time, the Hutu rebellion, that Hotel Rwanda covers. During this time hundreds of thousands of people died(800,000 to be exact) in only one hundred days. ONE HUNDRED DAYS! But wait a sec, don't fool yourself into thinking that Hutus killed Tutsis with M-16, AK-47, and tanks. The majority ( about 90%) of the people killed were killed with machetes. Yes they were sliced and hacked to death. So where in the world was the international community? Surely we can handle a few Rwandans with machetes? Well the U.S. and other nations had other really important things to take care of, like United Nations delegations and (in the case of the U.S.) gaining influence over Congolese natural resources ( Uranium). Plus, they're just Africans who care right? This is made all the worse for me when you consider that, when the U.N. finally decided to intervene, it took under a week to stop the conflict.
So I just realized that I've gone a bit over board with this (the funny thing is i haven't even started :P ). But I guess in the end it boils down to the fact that if the Rwandans were a "superpower" or a European country for that matter, none of this would have happened. If the Rwandans were White Anglo-Saxon Protestants, none of this would have happened. If the Rwandans were affluent, none of this would have happened.
I hate this movie. Not because its a bad movie, but because I can no longer watch it without getting sick to my stomach. For those of you who don't know, Hotel Rwanda is a chronicling of the Rwandan Genocide.Specifically, the heroism of a man named Paul Rusesabagina. I believe that we've talked a little about this particular event in class, but, in order for you to understand why i can no longer watch this movie, i believe a little elaboration is in order. During the age of imperialism Rwanda was controlled by the Germans. Then, after WWI, the Rwandan territory was taken from the Germans and in trusted to the Belgians. While the Belgians where in control of Rwanda they decided that they needed a way to separate the ruling class from the working/lower class. The Belgians based this separation on a myriad of ridiculous and morally offenses grounds including, among other things, nose width and skin pigment.Belgians picked those with lightest skin pigment and thinnest noses to rule, essentially picking those Rwandans who resembled them most closely to rule. These two classes of people were known as Hutu and Tutsi. Hutu being the lower class with the vast majority of the population (as per the usual in human societies), Tutsi being the ruling class with a vast minority of the total population. Isn't it funny how those who are already affluent get to chose what affluent people look like?! Hilarious right?
Now that you know how and why these people were separated/ segregated, it wont be hard for you to understand why these two sides feuded when the Belgians left Rwanda to its own devises. I mean seriously imagine it, you live in Rwanda, your trying to simple survive, then some super power walks in and says " Hey how ya doin? We're Belgium and we are going to be ruling you now. The way we're are gonna do this is by separating you into two groups:the rich and the poor. So all of those with thin noses and light skin please step forward, and everybody else....you've go a lot of work to do." So obviously when the Belgians leave the lower class is going to be out for blood, and guess what that's exactly what happens! Who would have guessed that the majority of people who had been stripped of their rights, their land, their dignity, and pretty much everything else, would be pissed?
It is this time, the Hutu rebellion, that Hotel Rwanda covers. During this time hundreds of thousands of people died(800,000 to be exact) in only one hundred days. ONE HUNDRED DAYS! But wait a sec, don't fool yourself into thinking that Hutus killed Tutsis with M-16, AK-47, and tanks. The majority ( about 90%) of the people killed were killed with machetes. Yes they were sliced and hacked to death. So where in the world was the international community? Surely we can handle a few Rwandans with machetes? Well the U.S. and other nations had other really important things to take care of, like United Nations delegations and (in the case of the U.S.) gaining influence over Congolese natural resources ( Uranium). Plus, they're just Africans who care right? This is made all the worse for me when you consider that, when the U.N. finally decided to intervene, it took under a week to stop the conflict.
So I just realized that I've gone a bit over board with this (the funny thing is i haven't even started :P ). But I guess in the end it boils down to the fact that if the Rwandans were a "superpower" or a European country for that matter, none of this would have happened. If the Rwandans were White Anglo-Saxon Protestants, none of this would have happened. If the Rwandans were affluent, none of this would have happened.
Movies
A movie on the PTK film list that I have seen is "Thank You for Smoking." It is the story of a spokesman for big tobacco, Nick Naylor, who's job is to defend the tobacco business against a skull and cross bones warning label on cigarette packages. During the movie he is kidnapped by a group of anti-smoking radicals who attempt to kill him with the use of nicotine patches. He survives nicotine poisoning only because of his own cigarette habit, but is left with the possibility of dying if smoking even one cigarette. There is an interesting part of the film where the spokespeople for alcohol and firearms join Nick in a meeting, and they mention how cigarettes kill more people than alcohol and guns combined. The movie covers Nick as he tries to put smoking in Hollywood films and defends big tobacco from lawsuits. Throughout the story Nick Naylor defends his career saying that, "I just need to pay the mortgage." I think this film puts into perspective some of the corrupt tactics used by affluent industries.
"Wall-E" is a movie that is not on the list, but I have seen it recently and I believe it should be listed. In the movie, the human race has covered the planet in garbage to the point that humans must abandon Earth. Humans have taken a "vacation" in outer space, while robots clean the trash from the planet. The human race lives on a huge star ship and every person travels using a scooter, as well no one can walk and has become obese. The movie gives some great examples of how humans have become dependent on machines. Of course the movie is mainly a robot love story, but it does have within it some very good examples of the diseases of affluence.
"Wall-E" is a movie that is not on the list, but I have seen it recently and I believe it should be listed. In the movie, the human race has covered the planet in garbage to the point that humans must abandon Earth. Humans have taken a "vacation" in outer space, while robots clean the trash from the planet. The human race lives on a huge star ship and every person travels using a scooter, as well no one can walk and has become obese. The movie gives some great examples of how humans have become dependent on machines. Of course the movie is mainly a robot love story, but it does have within it some very good examples of the diseases of affluence.
The Devil Wears Prada
First of all, let me say that i haven't actually seen very many of the movies listed on the PTK site. I don't really watch that many movies because I always get sidetracked and never manage to finish them...or I end up falling asleep. Anyway, I watched The Devil Wears Prada and loved it!!
This movie is about an acclaimed fashion magazine editor who gets a new assistant that is very unfamiliar with the lifestyles associated with her line of work. The new assistant (Anne Hathaway) secretly aspires to be a journalist while working for this extremely wealthy woman (Meryl Streep). Well, in the midst of working nonstop, Anne Hathaway loses sight of everything that's happening in her personal life. She becomes more and more wrapped up in work and fails to see that she is giving up everything else that used to be important to her.
I loved this movie so much because it shows the roles affluence plays in the real world. This whole movie was based on how influential this high fashion magazine editor was due to her wealth and patrons. This kinda goes into the fine arts aspect of things as well. I also liked the fact that in the end of the movie Anne Hathaway realized that it wasn't worth sacrificing her relationships and values in order to become more affluent in her career. I think that everyone has decisions to make and that before we make these decisions we look at every aspect of it before doing so. Affluence or wealth will always factor into this idea somewhere, but I guess it's about learning to not get wrapped up in it for fear of losing yourself in the mix.
This movie is about an acclaimed fashion magazine editor who gets a new assistant that is very unfamiliar with the lifestyles associated with her line of work. The new assistant (Anne Hathaway) secretly aspires to be a journalist while working for this extremely wealthy woman (Meryl Streep). Well, in the midst of working nonstop, Anne Hathaway loses sight of everything that's happening in her personal life. She becomes more and more wrapped up in work and fails to see that she is giving up everything else that used to be important to her.
I loved this movie so much because it shows the roles affluence plays in the real world. This whole movie was based on how influential this high fashion magazine editor was due to her wealth and patrons. This kinda goes into the fine arts aspect of things as well. I also liked the fact that in the end of the movie Anne Hathaway realized that it wasn't worth sacrificing her relationships and values in order to become more affluent in her career. I think that everyone has decisions to make and that before we make these decisions we look at every aspect of it before doing so. Affluence or wealth will always factor into this idea somewhere, but I guess it's about learning to not get wrapped up in it for fear of losing yourself in the mix.
Saturday, March 7, 2009
Movies and Affluence
Who Killed the Electric Car? Although I did not see this movie, I really wanted to. It played at the Moxie for a few weeks and one of my good friends saw it and thought it was great, although sad. The genre is basically that someone invents an electric car, this great, but the idea is not taken very far due to, I believe GM. GM had the car destroyed because they did not want to compete with this invention or let the public know of such invention. If the public found out about the car, they might not invest in GM's gas powered SUVs, which is what was their most popular vehicle. This is a great example of how affluence rules the world.
Stand and Deliver - I have this movie memorized because I had to watch it almost every year in high school. It's very good, though. Basically it's about a guy who decides to teach at a school in very poor, run down community. He believes in the students and eventually wants to teach them calculus. No one believes in the students including the other teachers, the student's parents, and community. The teacher struggles with administration throughout the movie. First the administration doesn't want him to teach calculus and laughs at him. Then when his students score the highest on a standardized math test, his students are accused of cheating. This movie shows how lack of affluence, too often leads to lack of respect. No one had faith in the students because they were poor, they couldn't have a high score on the test because they were.....poor. Although this movie was made a while back, I think that the same issues still exist. Psychology teaches that often someone will live up to the title that is received by others. I feel that this occurs in today's society, we give the poor a label that reflects that they are limited in their knowledge and work because of their status.
I felt that so many of the movies listed on the PTK website were great examples of the effect of affluence. The only movie on the PTK list that I didn't really care for was Boogie Nights. Just a little too graphic for my liking.
Stand and Deliver - I have this movie memorized because I had to watch it almost every year in high school. It's very good, though. Basically it's about a guy who decides to teach at a school in very poor, run down community. He believes in the students and eventually wants to teach them calculus. No one believes in the students including the other teachers, the student's parents, and community. The teacher struggles with administration throughout the movie. First the administration doesn't want him to teach calculus and laughs at him. Then when his students score the highest on a standardized math test, his students are accused of cheating. This movie shows how lack of affluence, too often leads to lack of respect. No one had faith in the students because they were poor, they couldn't have a high score on the test because they were.....poor. Although this movie was made a while back, I think that the same issues still exist. Psychology teaches that often someone will live up to the title that is received by others. I feel that this occurs in today's society, we give the poor a label that reflects that they are limited in their knowledge and work because of their status.
I felt that so many of the movies listed on the PTK website were great examples of the effect of affluence. The only movie on the PTK list that I didn't really care for was Boogie Nights. Just a little too graphic for my liking.
Films
I have seen quite a few of the films on the list. When I initially looked through it, I couldn't understand why some of the films were on there. However, after thinking about them through a different lense as Caron said, I am able to see the affluence issues within them. There are still a few I question like The Office (a show that I love by the way) and Weeds (also quite enjoyable). I guess I just don't think they would have been my choices for films relating to affluence.
However one I found particularly interesting was Erin Brockovich. This was one I couldn't initially understand through the lense of affluence. Now though, that's about all I can remember about it. (I need to get it out an watch it again this week.) Anyway, the main premise is a woman who is just trying to scrape by and take care of her three children, when she gets a job doing some clerical work in a small law firm. She ends up uncovering a huge class-action lawsuit involving a small country community and a large cooperation who has been dumping chemical waste ruining the community's ground water. The main paradox of affluence in this film is between the large cooperation (PG&E), and the people of the community, and even Erin herself. PG&E knows they are hurting people, but since they are so affluent, they are able to bury the law firm and the community in paper work. It seems like since they are affluent, they are calling the shots, and the community might never get the restitution they deserve. However, like any redeptive film, obviously the people and Erin triumph over the affluent in the end, and get what they deserve.
This film was very interesting to look at through the lense of affluence. I've been trying to look at all films this way, and just see what I can observe.
However one I found particularly interesting was Erin Brockovich. This was one I couldn't initially understand through the lense of affluence. Now though, that's about all I can remember about it. (I need to get it out an watch it again this week.) Anyway, the main premise is a woman who is just trying to scrape by and take care of her three children, when she gets a job doing some clerical work in a small law firm. She ends up uncovering a huge class-action lawsuit involving a small country community and a large cooperation who has been dumping chemical waste ruining the community's ground water. The main paradox of affluence in this film is between the large cooperation (PG&E), and the people of the community, and even Erin herself. PG&E knows they are hurting people, but since they are so affluent, they are able to bury the law firm and the community in paper work. It seems like since they are affluent, they are calling the shots, and the community might never get the restitution they deserve. However, like any redeptive film, obviously the people and Erin triumph over the affluent in the end, and get what they deserve.
This film was very interesting to look at through the lense of affluence. I've been trying to look at all films this way, and just see what I can observe.
Tuesday, March 3, 2009
Affluence in Film
I was very excited when I received Caron's email about possibly watching a movie in class. I love movies! I watch movies way more often than I watch regular cable, although lately I have watched a lot of television since I have become hooked on the ghost hunting shows. I consider watching ghost hunting shows to be my "homework" since I am going to be a ghost hunter someday. ; )
Anyway, back to the issue of affluence in film. I have watched several of the movies on the list, but there are also several more I have not seen. I am more of a Disney fan. :D I find the issue of affluence in film very interesting. I have never watched a movie looking for the paradox of affluence so I really had to think on some of the movies on the list. Like Caron, I had to switch to a different lens while viewing the movies once more in my mind.
One of the movies I have seen on the list that really stands out to me is Super Size Me. Talk about a disgusting movie. Unfortunately it was a very eye opening movie as well. I was forced to watch it while I was an intern for the health teacher in my high school last year. The movie talked about how bad for you McDonalds and fast food in general is. This issue is obviously related to affluence. Because we have more affluence, our nation has restaurants on every street corner, and people can afford to eat at them every day. Since we are eating crap at fast food restaurants every day we are seeing the so called diseases of affluence, obesity in particular. We are a fast paced nation and fast food helps us to keep going at that pace. As a nation we are also very focused on instant gratification. We are hungry now, so we want food now. We are not willing to take the time or put in the effort to prepare a much healthier lunch for ourselves. Also, we are a very indulgent society. We do not stop at a point where our needs are satisfied. We constantly want more. Not only is this reflected in our desire for wealth and affluence, it is evident in our food consumption. Do we need a super size order of French fries? Absolutely not. Do we want it, and are we going to get it even though we don't need it? Most likely. We have the affluence to be able to get more than what we need, and as a nation we are very irresponsible with that excess affluence. I won't even get into the issue of the trillions of dollars our nation is in debt and 700 billion dollar bailouts we dish out.
I have watched many of the other movies on the list, but Super Size Me was the one that stood out. Keep in mind that just because it stood out in my mind doesn't mean I want to watch it in class! Once is definitely enough for me! Some of the other movies I have seen were Clueless, Gone With the Wind (I was only like eight years old though), John Q, Lewis Black: Red, White, and Screwed, Ocean's Eleven, The Devil Wears Prada, and The Wizard of Oz. I am sure I have seen more of them, but these are the ones I can really remember anything about....well, except for Gone With the Wind. :D
In addition to all the movies on the list, I also saw The Simpsons and The Office at the bottom of the page. Let me take this time to officially cast my vote to watch both of these amazing shows! They are my two favorites! I think they are very related to affluence so we should definitely watch them. Does this mean I can show a Simpsons episode on one of my presentation days and an episode of The Office on the other day? Yes, I believe it does. Woohoo!
Anyway, back to the issue of affluence in film. I have watched several of the movies on the list, but there are also several more I have not seen. I am more of a Disney fan. :D I find the issue of affluence in film very interesting. I have never watched a movie looking for the paradox of affluence so I really had to think on some of the movies on the list. Like Caron, I had to switch to a different lens while viewing the movies once more in my mind.
One of the movies I have seen on the list that really stands out to me is Super Size Me. Talk about a disgusting movie. Unfortunately it was a very eye opening movie as well. I was forced to watch it while I was an intern for the health teacher in my high school last year. The movie talked about how bad for you McDonalds and fast food in general is. This issue is obviously related to affluence. Because we have more affluence, our nation has restaurants on every street corner, and people can afford to eat at them every day. Since we are eating crap at fast food restaurants every day we are seeing the so called diseases of affluence, obesity in particular. We are a fast paced nation and fast food helps us to keep going at that pace. As a nation we are also very focused on instant gratification. We are hungry now, so we want food now. We are not willing to take the time or put in the effort to prepare a much healthier lunch for ourselves. Also, we are a very indulgent society. We do not stop at a point where our needs are satisfied. We constantly want more. Not only is this reflected in our desire for wealth and affluence, it is evident in our food consumption. Do we need a super size order of French fries? Absolutely not. Do we want it, and are we going to get it even though we don't need it? Most likely. We have the affluence to be able to get more than what we need, and as a nation we are very irresponsible with that excess affluence. I won't even get into the issue of the trillions of dollars our nation is in debt and 700 billion dollar bailouts we dish out.
I have watched many of the other movies on the list, but Super Size Me was the one that stood out. Keep in mind that just because it stood out in my mind doesn't mean I want to watch it in class! Once is definitely enough for me! Some of the other movies I have seen were Clueless, Gone With the Wind (I was only like eight years old though), John Q, Lewis Black: Red, White, and Screwed, Ocean's Eleven, The Devil Wears Prada, and The Wizard of Oz. I am sure I have seen more of them, but these are the ones I can really remember anything about....well, except for Gone With the Wind. :D
In addition to all the movies on the list, I also saw The Simpsons and The Office at the bottom of the page. Let me take this time to officially cast my vote to watch both of these amazing shows! They are my two favorites! I think they are very related to affluence so we should definitely watch them. Does this mean I can show a Simpsons episode on one of my presentation days and an episode of The Office on the other day? Yes, I believe it does. Woohoo!
Monday, March 2, 2009
Issues of Affluence in Film
I have attached the PTK film list to this entry. Far from Heaven was on the Indie Film Channel yesterday, so I thought I would do some homework and watch the flick. This was also my first time having seen the movie in its entirety -- I've seen the middle, a minute here, a few minutes there, but never the film in its entirety. When I saw it on the PTK film list, I was intrigued, and when I saw it was on IFC yesterday, I put down the grading, shut down the computer, grabbed a beverage, kicked up the feet, and watched the flick.
One thing I find interesting is when I remove the "everyday life lens" to view life through a different lens. In this doctoral program, I have worn multiple lenses as I rethink issues associated with the policies that shape education and organizations that support education. Using multiple metaphors, I have a pair of brain lenses [where organizations are viewed as a brain], a pair of machine lenses [organizations are simply a machine], a pair of organism lenses [where an organization adapts, morphs, evolves, etc., to its environment], among others. And as is the result of viewing issues through new lenses, new perspectives emerge. The affluence lens allowed me to view Far from Heaven with a different perspective. I was watching not only for the homosexual and racial implications, but also the implications of affluence. Those perspectives made this viewing certainly interesting: the perfect [affuent] white, 1950s family risks losing everything [their affluence] because of preferences not affiliated with their social status [his homosexuality; her support of African-American issues]. They do lose all -- he loses his job, his family, his "accepted" lifestyle [if not the affluent "lifestyle" to which he was accustomed], yet as the film closes we suspect he gains his freedom and his dignity -- in a 1950s society generally intolerant of these issues. Her associations with the African-Americans in Hartford, however, do not allow for increased freedoms. She loses all -- the perceived affluence [although she is still in the suburbia home], her husband, her support of the town and perhaps her friends, and her African-American friend who moves to another city to escape the potential harm to his daughter that resulted in his friendship with a white woman. The film closes with the female protagonist, now a single mom with 2 kids in 1950s America, having lost all of her social support. The movie presents interesting questions -- especially when affluence does play such a role in the characters' success, whether they are the local socialites or the African-American owner of a business.
What movies have you seen on the list, and how do you see they play into affluence? What do you recall about them?
One thing I find interesting is when I remove the "everyday life lens" to view life through a different lens. In this doctoral program, I have worn multiple lenses as I rethink issues associated with the policies that shape education and organizations that support education. Using multiple metaphors, I have a pair of brain lenses [where organizations are viewed as a brain], a pair of machine lenses [organizations are simply a machine], a pair of organism lenses [where an organization adapts, morphs, evolves, etc., to its environment], among others. And as is the result of viewing issues through new lenses, new perspectives emerge. The affluence lens allowed me to view Far from Heaven with a different perspective. I was watching not only for the homosexual and racial implications, but also the implications of affluence. Those perspectives made this viewing certainly interesting: the perfect [affuent] white, 1950s family risks losing everything [their affluence] because of preferences not affiliated with their social status [his homosexuality; her support of African-American issues]. They do lose all -- he loses his job, his family, his "accepted" lifestyle [if not the affluent "lifestyle" to which he was accustomed], yet as the film closes we suspect he gains his freedom and his dignity -- in a 1950s society generally intolerant of these issues. Her associations with the African-Americans in Hartford, however, do not allow for increased freedoms. She loses all -- the perceived affluence [although she is still in the suburbia home], her husband, her support of the town and perhaps her friends, and her African-American friend who moves to another city to escape the potential harm to his daughter that resulted in his friendship with a white woman. The film closes with the female protagonist, now a single mom with 2 kids in 1950s America, having lost all of her social support. The movie presents interesting questions -- especially when affluence does play such a role in the characters' success, whether they are the local socialites or the African-American owner of a business.
What movies have you seen on the list, and how do you see they play into affluence? What do you recall about them?
3/2 -- Health paradoxes continued...
So here is my issue -- and it's a far cry from the massage therapy from last weekend. I will try to be quick and painless, but it's an issue that plagues me constantly.
1. A dear friend of mine is a regional manager for an eyecare company. He was in sales, etc... a basic pharmaceutical salesperson... but excelled in his position and therefore is now #2 or #3 with the company--Alcon. So... he moved to Kansas City. Alcon gave him $40,000 to move. That's on top of his salary. And... this company has given him ginormous big-screen plasma TVs, iPods, etc., as rewards for his work. His American Express bill in one month is more than I make in a year. He gets annual trips to Greece, Mexico, etc., as rewards from the company.
2. Another very close person in my life is diabetic. Rather than being encouraged to modify his eating behaviors and ascribe to a healthier lifestyle, he is always given more doses of insulin. He has transitioned from tablets to the shots, and that is how the doctors encourage him to keep his sugar levels in check -- more medication. This person spends over $500/month in medications alone, and [GRANTED... let me add this... he chooses to not change his behaviors: "my heart is fine; my arteries are fine; I'm in good health..." even though he may be 50 pounds overweight. He chooses not to see that... he listens to his cardiologist and other doctors rather than his doctor he sees for his diabetes... but I digress... ]... So my issue here is "we have a pill for that." It's easier for this person to pop a pill -- with the support of his physicians -- rather than walk a mile or eat a salad. I am certainly no dietician nor am I a health freak, but if I can ward off many of our Top 10 killers just by being a little smart about it, why would I choose otherwise?? ... And here it is: because I can get a pill for that. We have pills for everything...
3. And this is where 1 and 2 combine: I see from the Alcon exec's lifestyle why pills are pushed by physicians so much -- it's an incredible racket. The pharmaceuticals and the physicians keep each other in a nice little affluence lifestyle by introducing more pills and keeping us more dependent on them -- the physicians -- and the pills. I have HUGE issues with our system that offers the quick-fix rather than the long-term health. But long-term does not make the corporate healthcare moguls as wealthy right now...
I could argue this issue in finitum. I see too many situations where people are just put on more pills rather than encouraged to change behaviors. Please understand I am talking extremes here -- when patients are on multiple medications and physicians simply add another. We become so dependent that we are no longer able to make independent choices, and that bothers me.
I'll stop now. I have yet another healthcare story, but it ends well: someone did change, and the prognosis is oustanding. All is well, but he made a concerted effort for 6 months to change, and then he retested for some health issues. They were all gone. He has maintained the change as a lifestyle and all is well. His situation was 100% controllable by diet -- and the physician discouraged it because the friend refused to be medicated for something he felt he could control. And he did. Again, not with his doctor's support...
Now I'll stop.
1. A dear friend of mine is a regional manager for an eyecare company. He was in sales, etc... a basic pharmaceutical salesperson... but excelled in his position and therefore is now #2 or #3 with the company--Alcon. So... he moved to Kansas City. Alcon gave him $40,000 to move. That's on top of his salary. And... this company has given him ginormous big-screen plasma TVs, iPods, etc., as rewards for his work. His American Express bill in one month is more than I make in a year. He gets annual trips to Greece, Mexico, etc., as rewards from the company.
2. Another very close person in my life is diabetic. Rather than being encouraged to modify his eating behaviors and ascribe to a healthier lifestyle, he is always given more doses of insulin. He has transitioned from tablets to the shots, and that is how the doctors encourage him to keep his sugar levels in check -- more medication. This person spends over $500/month in medications alone, and [GRANTED... let me add this... he chooses to not change his behaviors: "my heart is fine; my arteries are fine; I'm in good health..." even though he may be 50 pounds overweight. He chooses not to see that... he listens to his cardiologist and other doctors rather than his doctor he sees for his diabetes... but I digress... ]... So my issue here is "we have a pill for that." It's easier for this person to pop a pill -- with the support of his physicians -- rather than walk a mile or eat a salad. I am certainly no dietician nor am I a health freak, but if I can ward off many of our Top 10 killers just by being a little smart about it, why would I choose otherwise?? ... And here it is: because I can get a pill for that. We have pills for everything...
3. And this is where 1 and 2 combine: I see from the Alcon exec's lifestyle why pills are pushed by physicians so much -- it's an incredible racket. The pharmaceuticals and the physicians keep each other in a nice little affluence lifestyle by introducing more pills and keeping us more dependent on them -- the physicians -- and the pills. I have HUGE issues with our system that offers the quick-fix rather than the long-term health. But long-term does not make the corporate healthcare moguls as wealthy right now...
I could argue this issue in finitum. I see too many situations where people are just put on more pills rather than encouraged to change behaviors. Please understand I am talking extremes here -- when patients are on multiple medications and physicians simply add another. We become so dependent that we are no longer able to make independent choices, and that bothers me.
I'll stop now. I have yet another healthcare story, but it ends well: someone did change, and the prognosis is oustanding. All is well, but he made a concerted effort for 6 months to change, and then he retested for some health issues. They were all gone. He has maintained the change as a lifestyle and all is well. His situation was 100% controllable by diet -- and the physician discouraged it because the friend refused to be medicated for something he felt he could control. And he did. Again, not with his doctor's support...
Now I'll stop.
Sunday, March 1, 2009
When I think of health and affluence I, too, think of healthcare. There are many other aspects encompassing the topic- healthy eating, exercise (and the lack thereof when people are affluent enough to afford laziness-inducing amenities), etc., but I feel these topics have been covered well enough on this blog, and although healthcare has as well, I have a lot more to say on that subject.
Last semester I became involved in a pretty big, several weeks long argument with my Political Science teacher about universal healthcare. Basically she said that such a system would cause people to not want to go to medical school because they wouldn't be making as much money, so we would have no doctors. Besides that, no one else would feel the need to work as hard because they wouldn't have too in order to receive healthcare- it would just be given to everyone regardless. Please don't tell on me, because after about three weeks of arguing through the online discussion board I finally gave up for fear that my grade might suffer if I kept claiming she was ignorant, but basically, I think this opinion is ignorant. Many of you may disagree with me as well, but as long as we don't turn this into some kind of holy war, I'm okay with that. And I welcome your opinions.
There are several things to think about here. As has already been discussed, we (as Americans) have access to the best medical technology on the planet, but it is only available if you can afford it. Healthcare is a business, a business that transforms human lives into dollar signs. I feel that we could benefit from some form of universal healthcare reform to reverse this travesty. When we look at the Canadian and British healthcare systems, it's easy to see that there are some holes. Waiting lists can be long and treatments may not be as advanced, but there is just as much evidence to the contrary and I'm almost inclined to believe that the media is strictly releasing information about rare occasions of the down sides peeking through (because the media is generally controlled by Republican fat cats who are categorically against such a system and definitely don't want one being imposed on American soil). Either way, something needs to be done. They say that no one goes without the ability to see a doctor in America because it is true that anyone can walk into an emergency room and be treated. However, emergency rooms are for emergencies. You can spend seven hours in one to get antibiotics or something of that nature and be billed later, but if you have a medical issue that is unidentifiable without tests, you're pretty much out of luck. Last year I was in and out of the emergency room a total of 32 times in a two month period for inexplicable heart problems which I couldn't get remedied without tests, but they refused to look deeper into the issue because I had no insurance. They said I needed to see a "primary care physician" and all they could do was help if and when my condition finally resulted in a heart attack. In that two months I nearly lost my job and was rushed away from work in this pre-heart attack state several times, so I was unable to save money to see a doctor. I began to realize the issue was going to kill me and managed to only recently finally gather the funds to see a primary care physician who ran just a few simple tests and determined I had a genetic potassium deficiency. A banana a day or potassium pills save my life on a daily basis.
This just all makes me wonder, especially in relation to affluence, if you have to already have money to receive healthcare, how many poverty stricken brilliant minds have we allowed to die because of something as simple as not knowing they needed to eat a banana every day to live?? How many of those brilliant, cast-aside minds had the potential to cure cancer themselves, but were unable to receive simple treatments for their own trivial conditions?
It's absolutely ridiculous.
Last semester I became involved in a pretty big, several weeks long argument with my Political Science teacher about universal healthcare. Basically she said that such a system would cause people to not want to go to medical school because they wouldn't be making as much money, so we would have no doctors. Besides that, no one else would feel the need to work as hard because they wouldn't have too in order to receive healthcare- it would just be given to everyone regardless. Please don't tell on me, because after about three weeks of arguing through the online discussion board I finally gave up for fear that my grade might suffer if I kept claiming she was ignorant, but basically, I think this opinion is ignorant. Many of you may disagree with me as well, but as long as we don't turn this into some kind of holy war, I'm okay with that. And I welcome your opinions.
There are several things to think about here. As has already been discussed, we (as Americans) have access to the best medical technology on the planet, but it is only available if you can afford it. Healthcare is a business, a business that transforms human lives into dollar signs. I feel that we could benefit from some form of universal healthcare reform to reverse this travesty. When we look at the Canadian and British healthcare systems, it's easy to see that there are some holes. Waiting lists can be long and treatments may not be as advanced, but there is just as much evidence to the contrary and I'm almost inclined to believe that the media is strictly releasing information about rare occasions of the down sides peeking through (because the media is generally controlled by Republican fat cats who are categorically against such a system and definitely don't want one being imposed on American soil). Either way, something needs to be done. They say that no one goes without the ability to see a doctor in America because it is true that anyone can walk into an emergency room and be treated. However, emergency rooms are for emergencies. You can spend seven hours in one to get antibiotics or something of that nature and be billed later, but if you have a medical issue that is unidentifiable without tests, you're pretty much out of luck. Last year I was in and out of the emergency room a total of 32 times in a two month period for inexplicable heart problems which I couldn't get remedied without tests, but they refused to look deeper into the issue because I had no insurance. They said I needed to see a "primary care physician" and all they could do was help if and when my condition finally resulted in a heart attack. In that two months I nearly lost my job and was rushed away from work in this pre-heart attack state several times, so I was unable to save money to see a doctor. I began to realize the issue was going to kill me and managed to only recently finally gather the funds to see a primary care physician who ran just a few simple tests and determined I had a genetic potassium deficiency. A banana a day or potassium pills save my life on a daily basis.
This just all makes me wonder, especially in relation to affluence, if you have to already have money to receive healthcare, how many poverty stricken brilliant minds have we allowed to die because of something as simple as not knowing they needed to eat a banana every day to live?? How many of those brilliant, cast-aside minds had the potential to cure cancer themselves, but were unable to receive simple treatments for their own trivial conditions?
It's absolutely ridiculous.
Thursday, February 26, 2009
Healthcare and Affluence
The affluent affect so many aspects of health care. Here are examples of just a few of the many aspects of health care that they affect:
1. Prescription drugs - many large pharmacueutical companies buy out the generic companies so that they can continue receiving the high price for their drug.
2. Sex Education - the affluent, for the most part feel that anything to do with sex should not be talked about and it should be left up to the individual or the individual's parents. Our country's pregnancy rate and abortion rate is out of control. I honestly believe that this is due to lack of knowledge and exposure. I think it is so crazy that the same people who are against abortion, are against sexual education. The affluent have made sex so hush - hush that teens would rather be unprotected then be seen buying the necessities at the local store. I also feel that birth control is way too hard to get a hold of. You shouldn't need a parent's permission. Yes some places can give it to you, but I believe that you still need a doctor's permission and who is going to take you to the doctor and sign for you if you are under 18, your parents. Other countries that have sexual education have way lower abortion and pregnancy rates. I think the US should realize that knowledge is not promoting the idea of sex, but simply educating. If our country is aware of the high abortion rates and pregnancies, then why are we not doing anything about it????
3. Our Best Health care - we are known for having the best health care....if you can afford it. As others have discussed in their blogs. The affluent have total control of the best health care received in the United States. If you cannot afford health care, then you either are denied (which is not suppose to occur, but does) or you have to sell everything you own to pay your bills. If you can barely afford health care then you'll probably have a provider that is always hounding you to fill out tons of forms so that they can try to prove that your injury cannot be payed by their company.
These are just a few of the many examples of how health care is ruled by the affluent. I could go on for hours and hours, but I'll just stop here.
1. Prescription drugs - many large pharmacueutical companies buy out the generic companies so that they can continue receiving the high price for their drug.
2. Sex Education - the affluent, for the most part feel that anything to do with sex should not be talked about and it should be left up to the individual or the individual's parents. Our country's pregnancy rate and abortion rate is out of control. I honestly believe that this is due to lack of knowledge and exposure. I think it is so crazy that the same people who are against abortion, are against sexual education. The affluent have made sex so hush - hush that teens would rather be unprotected then be seen buying the necessities at the local store. I also feel that birth control is way too hard to get a hold of. You shouldn't need a parent's permission. Yes some places can give it to you, but I believe that you still need a doctor's permission and who is going to take you to the doctor and sign for you if you are under 18, your parents. Other countries that have sexual education have way lower abortion and pregnancy rates. I think the US should realize that knowledge is not promoting the idea of sex, but simply educating. If our country is aware of the high abortion rates and pregnancies, then why are we not doing anything about it????
3. Our Best Health care - we are known for having the best health care....if you can afford it. As others have discussed in their blogs. The affluent have total control of the best health care received in the United States. If you cannot afford health care, then you either are denied (which is not suppose to occur, but does) or you have to sell everything you own to pay your bills. If you can barely afford health care then you'll probably have a provider that is always hounding you to fill out tons of forms so that they can try to prove that your injury cannot be payed by their company.
These are just a few of the many examples of how health care is ruled by the affluent. I could go on for hours and hours, but I'll just stop here.
Wednesday, February 25, 2009
Of all the areas of affluence, I think that health is the most important because it serves as the basis for everything else surrounding this paradox. Our health consists of the mental, physical, and emotional states that we experience in life, and I think that affluence has both positive and negative effects.
Ryan made a good point about how we as Americans are unhealthy even though we have all the resources not to be. Why is it that we are so unhealthy and unhappy at the same time? Maybe the two coincide with each other...I know they do for me personally. I'm a poor college student who can't afford to only eatww organic food. I like ramen noodles and frozen pizza. I find this ironic because I continue to pay the gym membership that I can barely afford as opposed to spending that money on healthier food.
I do believe that the affluent have more access to leading healthier lifestyles. Celebrities hire personal trainers and chefs and show off their big kitchens on television all the time. This leads us to believe that we have to live up to this standard and we find it overwhelming when we cannot. In many ways we look up to the wealthy because we feel that they have something that we don't. Like we are missing out on "the good life" because they are somehow better than us with all their money.
Being affluent does allow for more opportunities when it comes to health care. Coming from someone who doesn't have health care, money is definitely an important issue. I find it interesting to see how other countries have advanced their society and have universal health care even though the United States is the more affluent nation and we still have uninsured citizens. Other countries may have less resources than us, but they still manage to keep their citizens happy and healthy. Why can't we?
Ryan made a good point about how we as Americans are unhealthy even though we have all the resources not to be. Why is it that we are so unhealthy and unhappy at the same time? Maybe the two coincide with each other...I know they do for me personally. I'm a poor college student who can't afford to only eatww organic food. I like ramen noodles and frozen pizza. I find this ironic because I continue to pay the gym membership that I can barely afford as opposed to spending that money on healthier food.
I do believe that the affluent have more access to leading healthier lifestyles. Celebrities hire personal trainers and chefs and show off their big kitchens on television all the time. This leads us to believe that we have to live up to this standard and we find it overwhelming when we cannot. In many ways we look up to the wealthy because we feel that they have something that we don't. Like we are missing out on "the good life" because they are somehow better than us with all their money.
Being affluent does allow for more opportunities when it comes to health care. Coming from someone who doesn't have health care, money is definitely an important issue. I find it interesting to see how other countries have advanced their society and have universal health care even though the United States is the more affluent nation and we still have uninsured citizens. Other countries may have less resources than us, but they still manage to keep their citizens happy and healthy. Why can't we?
The Health Paradox
When it comes to the issue of health and affluence, I think this is where one of the biggest paradoxes of our society lies. We are doing really poor as a country when it comes to both physical health and mental health. We are one of the most affluent nations in the world yet we are unhealthy. And not only are we unhealthy, as a nation we are unhappy as well. We are experiencing the so called "diseases of affluence" which are the problems that other developing countries with far less affluence do not see. Examples of these diseases are cancer due to drinking and smoking, obesity, heart disease, and depression.
Like Ryan said in his post, having the luxury of vehicles is detrimental to our health. Because of cars, we hardly ever get any exercise unless we make a conscious effort to get in any exercise during the day. With our advanced technology, most of us aren't making the extra effort to exercise. We are busy talking on our phones, playing video games, surfing the internet, or Facebook stalking people. ; )
Another problem leading to these diseases is our eating habits. Because we are an affluent nation, we have endless possibilities when it comes to food, and we tend to eat foods that taste the best, even though they may not be good for us. Also, we are a fast paced nation, and we have the restaurants to keep up with it. In less than a minute we can pull up to a drive through, order a two thousand calorie meal, pay for it, and start eating it. Fast food is good, but it comes at a price. Because we are not willing to give meal preparation any of our time, we sacrifice the healthiness of our food. Sure we can order a so called healthy option, but it is more expensive. As a college student, I don't have the extra money to spare to buy a meal that is less filling and less tastey at a higher price.
Finally when it comes to the mental health side of things, we are unhappy. Like I said before, we see depression everywhere. But why? We have so much, so how could we possibly be unhappy? In the United States we are constantly pushed to be better than everyone else so when we aren't, it upsets us. Also sometimes the fact that we do have so much available to us can get us down. I know for myself sometimes I just wish someone would tell me what to do with my life, because the thought that I have so many options, yet none of them appeal to me depresses me. A lot of times Americans compare themselves to the extremely affluent such as celebrities, and it depresses them that they feel they can never achieve this level of success.
Overall, I think there are a lot of positives to health and affluence like Christina stated, but there are definitely negatives as well.
Like Ryan said in his post, having the luxury of vehicles is detrimental to our health. Because of cars, we hardly ever get any exercise unless we make a conscious effort to get in any exercise during the day. With our advanced technology, most of us aren't making the extra effort to exercise. We are busy talking on our phones, playing video games, surfing the internet, or Facebook stalking people. ; )
Another problem leading to these diseases is our eating habits. Because we are an affluent nation, we have endless possibilities when it comes to food, and we tend to eat foods that taste the best, even though they may not be good for us. Also, we are a fast paced nation, and we have the restaurants to keep up with it. In less than a minute we can pull up to a drive through, order a two thousand calorie meal, pay for it, and start eating it. Fast food is good, but it comes at a price. Because we are not willing to give meal preparation any of our time, we sacrifice the healthiness of our food. Sure we can order a so called healthy option, but it is more expensive. As a college student, I don't have the extra money to spare to buy a meal that is less filling and less tastey at a higher price.
Finally when it comes to the mental health side of things, we are unhappy. Like I said before, we see depression everywhere. But why? We have so much, so how could we possibly be unhappy? In the United States we are constantly pushed to be better than everyone else so when we aren't, it upsets us. Also sometimes the fact that we do have so much available to us can get us down. I know for myself sometimes I just wish someone would tell me what to do with my life, because the thought that I have so many options, yet none of them appeal to me depresses me. A lot of times Americans compare themselves to the extremely affluent such as celebrities, and it depresses them that they feel they can never achieve this level of success.
Overall, I think there are a lot of positives to health and affluence like Christina stated, but there are definitely negatives as well.
The Dark Side of Health and Affluence
As Christina has already covered some of the positive aspects of health and affluence, I cannot help but think about the numerous negative side effects.
I would like to point out that although America is suppose to be the richest, most powerful, most affluent nation; out of the top industrialized nations the U.S. is the only country that does not provide some form of health care that covers all of its citizens. America also continues to drop in worldwide rankings of infant mortality rate and life expectancy. On the positive side (I guess) America does rank highest in cost and holds the best cancer survival rates. (although also has the highest cancer rates)
So, yes, somewhere in here is a huge paradox, but where does this come from? Although I am almost purely speculating, I cannot help but believe that it is a direct result of affluence gone wrong. America has a great abundance in unhealthy food that is all too often considered "edible," as well it seems 'healthy' food is extremely rare to encounter (if such a thing exists anymore). America also has an obvious abundance in vehicles, where it seems rather than walking a block or two, people wouldn't think twice about missing out on the opportunity to drive. I believe the role or dependence on vehicles in society can have negative effects on the health of the population. I believe that many times America's affluence creates it's own unhealthy lifestyle. Of course all of this goes without mentioning the possible corruption involved in America's health care system.
Anyways, although I am certain there are numerous positive effects in association with health and affluence, I am certain that in America there seems to be lack of affluence in terms of health.
I would like to point out that although America is suppose to be the richest, most powerful, most affluent nation; out of the top industrialized nations the U.S. is the only country that does not provide some form of health care that covers all of its citizens. America also continues to drop in worldwide rankings of infant mortality rate and life expectancy. On the positive side (I guess) America does rank highest in cost and holds the best cancer survival rates. (although also has the highest cancer rates)
So, yes, somewhere in here is a huge paradox, but where does this come from? Although I am almost purely speculating, I cannot help but believe that it is a direct result of affluence gone wrong. America has a great abundance in unhealthy food that is all too often considered "edible," as well it seems 'healthy' food is extremely rare to encounter (if such a thing exists anymore). America also has an obvious abundance in vehicles, where it seems rather than walking a block or two, people wouldn't think twice about missing out on the opportunity to drive. I believe the role or dependence on vehicles in society can have negative effects on the health of the population. I believe that many times America's affluence creates it's own unhealthy lifestyle. Of course all of this goes without mentioning the possible corruption involved in America's health care system.
Anyways, although I am certain there are numerous positive effects in association with health and affluence, I am certain that in America there seems to be lack of affluence in terms of health.
Tuesday, February 24, 2009
We're writing about messages...right?
So, I must confess after reading Caron's post I wasn't sure if I should write about messages or the relationship of health and affluence. And I probably have more to write about messages...but here goes nothing:
I think there is a huge positive correlation between health and affluence. For instance the affluent are those that generally have good health care, while those with little money generally have poor health care. If an affluent individual (like Magic Johnson) for instance is diagnosed with HIV, he has much better access to all of the state of the art, new treatments. He can get all of the anti-retrovirals he could possibly need. A person who doesn't have much money with the same diagnosis (like someone in East Africa) is likely to get little to no treatment, and will thus probably die sooner.
This is a modern day example, but these things have been going on throughout history. When Alexander Fleming discovered penicillin, and its medicinal value, who do you think began to reap its benefits first? The affluent of course. They had the money to afford the treatment, so they got it.
And let's briefly look at the impact of affluent individuals on medical research. Where does the funding come from for all of these medical research projects? Some of it comes from the government and taxpayers, but a large portion also comes from affluent individuals. Without these affluent individuals, many of the medical discoveries we know of today may have not yet been discovered.
In closing I would like to say that I need a message.
I think there is a huge positive correlation between health and affluence. For instance the affluent are those that generally have good health care, while those with little money generally have poor health care. If an affluent individual (like Magic Johnson) for instance is diagnosed with HIV, he has much better access to all of the state of the art, new treatments. He can get all of the anti-retrovirals he could possibly need. A person who doesn't have much money with the same diagnosis (like someone in East Africa) is likely to get little to no treatment, and will thus probably die sooner.
This is a modern day example, but these things have been going on throughout history. When Alexander Fleming discovered penicillin, and its medicinal value, who do you think began to reap its benefits first? The affluent of course. They had the money to afford the treatment, so they got it.
And let's briefly look at the impact of affluent individuals on medical research. Where does the funding come from for all of these medical research projects? Some of it comes from the government and taxpayers, but a large portion also comes from affluent individuals. Without these affluent individuals, many of the medical discoveries we know of today may have not yet been discovered.
In closing I would like to say that I need a message.
Monday, February 23, 2009
Health & Affluence -- shifting gears
OOPS! Someone was a little preoccupied at an Oscar-watching party last night to post a blog! Sorry! My apologies for shirking my duties, but actually, I'm going to make myself feel better and go with the notion that I was investigating the role of affluence on this celebratory night for the art of film -- or this genre of fine art. But... on to the next topic.
So let's move to another topic -- shifting gears to discuss the issues of health and affluence. Let me share a guilty pleasure moment that turned to guilt: I had an hour and a half hot stone massage Saturday. I generally get massages 2-3 times a year: during finals weeks in May and December, and then for a friend's birthday [generally]. So thanks to these discussions we have had, I was in the massage, enjoying the ambience and environment, when it hit me. The paradox of affluence. I suddenly had pangs of guilt for enjoying this simple healing art -- because those kids in Mumbai sure aren't gettin' this! So rather than relaxing, enjoying the moment, listening to the soothing waters trickle over some rock facade in the corner of the darkened room -- I experienced guilt for even being in that scenario. Now... if massage is one of the healing arts ... OH... and I had added eucalyptus and lavendar for their soothing herbal qualities, which did not help the guilt quotient ... but if massage is one of the historic healing arts [one sign in the massage studio noted massage has been used for 5,000 years], who, historically, had access to the healing qualities of this? The affluent. Kings, Queens. If you have been to Hot Springs [yes, I also bet on ponies], then you are aware of the health qualities associated with that region's hot springs. Many during the early 1900s flocked there to participate in its healing waters. And who were they? Yes, the affluent -- presidents, wives of presidents, kings, queens, business moguls, etc.
Alas... here's the point: yes, I do believe there is a correlation between affluence and health, and then I also see where this paradox plays into our understanding of what healthy is. I do, however, also know I have steered off the mark for the issue of health and affluence, but I confess: I had Jordan's multiple voices going through my head, having their own discussion of the issue of affluence and health and what my presence at this time had to do with my own and others' perceptions of the paradox of affluence. Regardless, the massage was not nearly as relaxing and mentally cleansing as it had been in the past. I blame you all.
So let's move to another topic -- shifting gears to discuss the issues of health and affluence. Let me share a guilty pleasure moment that turned to guilt: I had an hour and a half hot stone massage Saturday. I generally get massages 2-3 times a year: during finals weeks in May and December, and then for a friend's birthday [generally]. So thanks to these discussions we have had, I was in the massage, enjoying the ambience and environment, when it hit me. The paradox of affluence. I suddenly had pangs of guilt for enjoying this simple healing art -- because those kids in Mumbai sure aren't gettin' this! So rather than relaxing, enjoying the moment, listening to the soothing waters trickle over some rock facade in the corner of the darkened room -- I experienced guilt for even being in that scenario. Now... if massage is one of the healing arts ... OH... and I had added eucalyptus and lavendar for their soothing herbal qualities, which did not help the guilt quotient ... but if massage is one of the historic healing arts [one sign in the massage studio noted massage has been used for 5,000 years], who, historically, had access to the healing qualities of this? The affluent. Kings, Queens. If you have been to Hot Springs [yes, I also bet on ponies], then you are aware of the health qualities associated with that region's hot springs. Many during the early 1900s flocked there to participate in its healing waters. And who were they? Yes, the affluent -- presidents, wives of presidents, kings, queens, business moguls, etc.
Alas... here's the point: yes, I do believe there is a correlation between affluence and health, and then I also see where this paradox plays into our understanding of what healthy is. I do, however, also know I have steered off the mark for the issue of health and affluence, but I confess: I had Jordan's multiple voices going through my head, having their own discussion of the issue of affluence and health and what my presence at this time had to do with my own and others' perceptions of the paradox of affluence. Regardless, the massage was not nearly as relaxing and mentally cleansing as it had been in the past. I blame you all.
Sunday, February 22, 2009
Affluence/showing off
I honestly don't have much to say about the fine arts beyond what I've already posted in my last blog and several different replies, so this will be pretty short. I just finished watching the last half hour or so of the Academy Awards (which I stumbled upon completely on accident- I haven't been a big follower since I was a kid), and I thought there was some pretty significant relevance to the paradox of affluence in this celebration of the less-than-fine arts.
The cost of red carpet apparel could feed, vaccinate, and possibly purchase an entire continent:
The cost of red carpet apparel could feed, vaccinate, and possibly purchase an entire continent:
These are $3 million shoes made and worn for the express purpose of glamorizing an actress on the red carpet.
Cost of this entire ensemble is approx. 7 mil
Cost of shoes: 1mil
Cost of necklace: 27 mil
This dress at least cost me my eyesight; monetary value unknown
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


