Tuesday, January 27, 2009

Myers-Briggs Type Indicator... The Personality Horoscope?

I did manage to find a short and sweet video that covered much about the basics of the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator. Many of the other videos about the MBTI were very boring and seemed to lack any clear information whatsoever.


I also found an online test, one of the few that are free, at http://www.humanmetrics.com/cgi-win/JTypes2.asp. However, the results that I received from this test seemed very inaccurate and unworthy of posting, but hopefully someone else may find great use of it. :)

While searching for information on the MBTI, I could not help but notice that many people hold great criticism for the test. It is believed there could be just about every possible problem with the test, ranging from its reliability to its practical application for career planning. Personally, I could not agree more, I feel as though the test may as well have asked if I like donuts or bagels and then give me an IQ evaluation. At best I think the MBTI would only tell me something I already knew, that is if it were reliable enough and concrete enough to do so. I find the possible results of the test to be so vague that they could possibly apply to anyone depending on any numerous circumstances. Although I do understand that the test is about preference, I cannot help but feel that it is overall flawed. I can only hope that the results tomorrow morning will change my mind, but I do have my doubts.

3 comments:

  1. I agree with your thoughts on the test's reliability. It seems impossible to determine an individual's personality from simple multiple choice questions, most with only two options. I'll be interested to see how mine turns out as well, but I'm sure my skepticism won't be removed.
    Also, I went to the humanmetrics.com website, and wasn't impressed.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Although I would tend to agree with both your opinions, I feel compelled to present my slightly different take. First, I agree that this test should do nothing but tell you things you already know, if it didn’t it wouldn't be a very good personality test lol, but I think the importance of this test lies somewhere within your response to the outcome. The validity of this test is also in question. But it seems to me that the validity of any test, especially a personality test in which the answers should already be clear to you, should be determined by its results. Of course the test is going to be affected by how you’re feeling that day, but I was always under the assumption that your personality takes place post-thought and therefore should show up no matter what. but regardless of that I still side with you on the premise that even if this test shows me something it will hopefully tell me what I already know to be true and, I am certain, it won’t change anything fundamental about me :P

    ReplyDelete
  3. I went to http://www.humanmetrics.com and felt that my results were somewhat accurate. Someone else should take the test and post what careers the test suggested for them. The careers the test suggested for me included counseling, psychology, education, management, politics, science, or physician. Honestly I have thought of careers in these categories, but what categories did the website not cover? I don't know if I was receiving an accurate response or not. Someone else take the test and see if the careers that the test suggests matches up with preferred career choice.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.