OK, so I am usually skeptical about anything psychology, so I was not sure what to think about the MBTI. I did quite a bit of searching but found no more than what was posted to be relevant. I did find a lot of criticism and debates on the validity of the subject of personality type tests, but I think that I want to experience one before I make my decision as to how valid or reliable they are. I do feel that there has to be way more than 16 different personality types out there. I took the personality test on the human metrics site and was not impressed with it, so I have hopes the MBTI is significantly more accurate. It did not seem to put me in the right box. I find it a little depressing to think that everyone could be put in a little box and be completely defined. There is hopefully a great deal more to every one's personality than this. I guess it can work if it is only for a job.
On a more optimistic note, I am actually kind of excited to get our results back. Typically I only believe what can be rationally explained and you don't get a whole lot of that in psychology. At this point in my life I am open for ideas no matter what form they may be in. Maybe that has something to do with the fact that I am still so up in the air about my major, but I am hoping that this can give me a better idea of what field will be suitable for me. (However, I would take suggestions from strangers at this point.) :)
So I am going to stay open minded and see what the results bring. I actually hope that my mind is changed as to how reliable these types of tests are.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
That's interesting, Abby. If I remember correctly it seems like everyone else who took the humanmetrics test mostly agreed with their results. I haven't taken it yet so I can't do anything more than speculate, but my first instinct would be to side with you on the issue for exactly the same reasons. How can we all fit into one little category, especially when there are only sixteen options? Don't you think we shouldn't speak so simply about such complex things? It is a lot like most of the aspects of Psychology in that there is no definite, scientific method for proving such things.
ReplyDeleteI think bringing that point up was the only reason I got an A in my psych class- I was naturally argumentative about nearly every week's topic, but even as I so consistently played devil's advocate (thereby angering several people), no one could technically prove me wrong...