Tuesday, January 27, 2009

Carl Jung and the MBTI

When reading about the MBTI, I actually became more interested in the theories on which it was based rather than the actual results of the test. Since I am planning (at least for the moment) on entering the psychology field, I decided to do a little research on Carl Jung, the psychiatrist whose theories inspired the MBTI.

I found this on http://webspace.ship.edu/cgboer/jung.html

"Jung developed a personality typology that has become so popular that some people don't realize he did anything else! It begins with the distinction between introversion and extroversion. Introverts are people who prefer their internal world of thoughts, feelings, fantasies, dreams, and so on, while extroverts prefer the external world of things and people and activities.
The words have become confused with ideas like shyness and sociability, partially because introverts tend to be shy and extroverts tend to be sociable. But Jung intended for them to refer more to whether your ("ego") more often faced toward the persona and outer reality, or toward the collective unconscious and its archetypes. In that sense, the introvert is somewhat more mature than the extrovert. Our culture, of course, values the extrovert much more. And Jung warned that we all tend to value our own type most!

Whether we are introverts or extroverts, we need to deal with the world, inner and outer. And each of us has our preferred ways of dealing with it, ways we are comfortable with and good at. Jung suggests there are four basic ways, or functions:

The first is sensing. Sensing means what it says: getting information by means of the senses. A sensing person is good at looking and listening and generally getting to know the world. Jung called this one of the irrational functions, meaning that it involved perception rather than judging of information.

The second is thinking. Thinking means evaluating information or ideas rationally, logically. Jung called this a rational function, meaning that it involves decision making or judging, rather than simple intake of information.

The third is intuiting. Intuiting is a kind of perception that works outside of the usual conscious processes. It is irrational or perceptual, like sensing, but comes from the complex integration of large amounts of information, rather than simple seeing or hearing. Jung said it was like seeing around corners.

The fourth is feeling. Feeling, like thinking, is a matter of evaluating information, this time by weighing one's overall, emotional response. Jung calls it rational, obviously not in the usual sense of the word."

After reading that information, I can see just how closely tied the MBTI is to Carl Jung's theories and beliefs.

If there is one thing I have learned from my abnormal psychology class this semester, it's that we aren't that far removed from the days where the mentally ill were considered witches and bleeding a patient was the standard treatment for any mental disorder from schizophrenia to depression. I understand that most of the people who are taking the MBTI are not mentally ill, but it is because of the research done in order to cure mentally ill patients that we have the information regarding our unconscious mind and personality. But since we aren't that far removed, I believe that we still have a long way to go when it comes to figuring out the mind. For now the MBTI is one of the best indicators as to personality type, but who knows what will be discovered within our lifetime?

When looking at why companies use the MBTI, perhaps it is best summarized by the man whose theory on which it is based. Carl Jung once noted, "The meeting of two personalities is like the contact of two chemical substances: if there is any reaction, both are transformed." Companies are looking to see how the different personalities each individual has will interact, and how they will complement each other. Will it lead to an explosion of disasterous proportions or rather will one's strengths fill in the gap where another is lacking? Businesses that use the MBTI are looking for ways make the business run as efficiently as possible. By taking the personality test, most likely the company will be able to see where certain people might clash and others may work well together.

As an ending thought, I find it very interesting that the idea of the personality test in a way contradicts the philosophy of Carl Jung. He once stated that no one is merely extroverted or introverted, they are always a combination. By taking a personality test, we are being put into one box or another. As for myself, I believe I am equally as extroverted as I am introverted. I am very excited to see what the results say, though. I do think the results of the test can change over time as we grow and develop our minds so my advice is to take the results with a grain of salt.

Now that I have done my critical thinking for the day, I am off to bake some bread! :D

2 comments:

  1. Your post was very well thought out and presented, Jordan. I like your perspective on this topic because it is different from mine and therefore forces me to open my mind a little. It is definitely true that the psychology field has come a long way, and maybe more light will be shed on this whole personality type thing. After taking the human metrics test, which is based on the work of Carl Jung, I found the results to be a fairly generalized but accurate portrayal of my personality type. Why yes, I will tell you the results, as you are surely so eager to hear them! Here goes:
    YOUR TYPE
    E N F P
    Strength of the preferences %
    78 25 25 22

    This basically means that I am pretty outgoing, excitable, emotional, and kind of flaky...which is a decent description of me most of the time, I suppose. According to the career indicator I should be a journalist, musician, or PR specialist. Sounds good to me.
    Other ENFPs include Mark Twain, Bill Cosby, and Oprah. Cool, huh?

    P.S. Keep me updated on that Abnormal Psych class. That sounds fascinating to me. I really wish I would've taken that this semester instead of opting for Sociology, which is beginning to seriously annoy me!

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.